India's Selection Conundrum: Karun Nair’s Test Return Sparks Heated Debate

by Themba Sweet July 24, 2025 Sports 18
India's Selection Conundrum: Karun Nair’s Test Return Sparks Heated Debate

Karun Nair's Rollercoaster Journey Back to Test Cricket

Karun Nair, once touted as India’s next batting star, has found himself thrust back into the spotlight after a surprise recall to the Test squad in 2025. What’s most striking is the gap—seven long years away from the highest level—followed by a comeback fueled by raw numbers and gritty performances in domestic cricket. In the 2024/25 Ranji Trophy, Nair piled up 863 runs at an impressive average just shy of 54, finishing among the leading run-scorers for Vidarbha. Critics and fans alike quickly noticed—this was a man playing hungry, with maybe a point to prove.

The IPL 2025 punched his ticket into mainstream conversation again. While many discounted domestic form in favor of flashy T20 performances, Nair’s match-winning 87* against Jasprit Bumrah’s Mumbai Indians got everyone talking. Unlike some hopefuls, he didn’t shy away from the discourse either—pointing out the need to appreciate both consistent runs in first-class cricket and standout moments in the IPL, especially while picking squads for grueling Test series.

The Selection Squeeze: Experience vs Form

Despite this, the Indian selectors pulled a surprise by omitting Nair from the Champions Trophy 2025 squad, sticking instead with known commodities like KL Rahul and Shreyas Iyer. Their rationale was pretty clear: Rahul brings added value as a backup wicketkeeper, while Iyer has quietly strung together reliable performances in the middle order. Former India legend Sunil Gavaskar weighed in as well, insisting that squad roles and balances matter just as much as red-hot form. It’s not always about sheer numbers—you need someone who can step in behind the stumps in a crunch, or absorb pressure in the middle order on tough pitches.

For Nair, it’s a brutal reminder of how fierce the competition is, especially when you’re fighting to break into a side stacked with battle-hardened pros and bright-futured youngsters. India’s selectors clearly value stability, but they also want that spark—someone who can grab a chance and run with it, especially on tricky international surfaces where domestic dominance doesn’t always translate.

Now, Nair’s story takes another turn as he returns to Karnataka for the 2025-26 domestic season, leaving behind a successful stretch with Vidarbha. Fans in Bengaluru are thrilled—he’s a local hero, and the hope is his new form will inspire a strong run for the team. But for the national squad, the question lingers: can Nair’s fresh domestic runs convert to meaningful Test knocks, especially with younger talents breathing down his neck?

The Karun Nair debate isn’t just about one batter’s fate—it’s about how India weighs old guard reliability against the irresistible pull of new form, how the balance between red-ball grind and IPL glory shapes new squads, and whether selectors will stick to their guns or gamble on redemption tales. With the new domestic season underway, all eyes are on Nair—and the real drama is just getting started.

Author: Themba Sweet
Themba Sweet
I am a news journalist with a passion for writing about daily news in Africa. With over 20 years of experience in the field, I strive to deliver accurate and insightful stories. My work aims to inform and educate the public on the continent’s current affairs and developments.

18 Comments

  • naresh g said:
    July 26, 2025 AT 16:42
    Wait, so Nair scored 863 runs in Ranji... and they still picked Rahul? I mean, come on. That’s not selection, that’s a loyalty program.
  • Brajesh Yadav said:
    July 28, 2025 AT 03:24
    This is why Indian cricket is broken. 🤦‍♂️ They reward the loud ones and ignore the quiet warriors. Nair didn’t even get a sniff. #JusticeForNair 🙏🔥
  • Sumit Garg said:
    July 28, 2025 AT 08:46
    The selection committee, in their infinite wisdom, has once again elevated mediocrity over merit. The fact that KL Rahul’s wicketkeeping utility is being prioritized over a batsman who averaged 54 in first-class cricket-while playing on subcontinental pitches-is not just statistically indefensible; it is a philosophical betrayal of the very ethos of Test cricket.
  • Sneha N said:
    July 28, 2025 AT 10:13
    I just... I can't believe how they treat him. 😢💔 He worked so hard. All those lonely hours in the nets... and now? Silence. 🌙
  • Manjunath Nayak BP said:
    July 29, 2025 AT 07:41
    Look, let’s cut the crap-this isn’t about form, it’s about politics. The BCCI doesn’t want a guy who talks back, who dares to say the IPL matters as much as Ranji. Nair called them out, and now they’re burying him under a pile of ‘experience’ and ‘balance.’ Meanwhile, the same selectors gave a Test spot to a guy who got out for 3 against England last year because he ‘has potential.’ Potential? Bro, Nair’s got 863 runs and a hundred against a side that’s now in the top 5. Who’s the real potential here?
  • Tulika Singh said:
    July 30, 2025 AT 09:14
    Sometimes the quietest players carry the heaviest burdens. Let’s honor that.
  • Govind Gupta said:
    July 31, 2025 AT 13:32
    Nair’s comeback feels like a quiet storm-no fanfare, no hype, just runs. And honestly? That’s the kind of grit India needs more of. Not the flashy 40-ball fifties, but the 8-hour, 150-run anchors who make the bowlers bleed.
  • tushar singh said:
    August 2, 2025 AT 09:49
    Hey, Karun-you’re not forgotten. Keep grinding. Bengaluru’s cheering for you. 🙌💛
  • Robert Shealtiel said:
    August 2, 2025 AT 11:03
    I dont know why people care so much about this guy
  • Marrissa Davis said:
    August 4, 2025 AT 01:50
    I just think it’s beautiful when someone comes back from the edge and just... plays. No ego, no noise. Karun’s doing that. And honestly? That’s the kind of player I’d want on my team.
  • Sean Brison said:
    August 4, 2025 AT 18:41
    Honestly, if you look at the last 5 Test series India played, the middle order collapsed in 4 of them. Nair’s the guy who doesn’t panic under pressure. He’s not flashy, but he’s got the temperament for Karachi or Cape Town. They’re leaving him out for a backup keeper? That’s not strategy-that’s a panic button.
  • Norm Rockwell said:
    August 6, 2025 AT 14:02
    You think this is about cricket? Nah. The BCCI’s got a secret deal with the IPL franchises to keep guys like Nair out. Why? Because if he gets in the Test team, he’ll start demanding higher domestic pay. And then the IPL teams lose their cheap labor. This isn’t selection-it’s corporate sabotage.
  • Lawrence Abiamuwe said:
    August 7, 2025 AT 23:32
    Respect to Karun Nair for maintaining discipline and focus despite being overlooked. His journey exemplifies true professionalism. The selectors must consider consistency over fleeting moments.
  • Dan Ripma said:
    August 8, 2025 AT 10:34
    In the grand theatre of Indian cricket, Karun Nair is the tragic hero-never given the final act, yet performing as if the stage were infinite. His silence speaks louder than any press conference.
  • amrin shaikh said:
    August 10, 2025 AT 08:08
    Nair? Please. He’s a glorified domestic player who got lucky with good pitches. You think he’d survive a 5-day match in England? He’d get bowled over by a 100kph seamer. Meanwhile, Iyer’s got the technique to handle pace and spin. This isn’t even a debate.
  • jai utkarsh said:
    August 11, 2025 AT 13:20
    The entire Indian cricket establishment is a cult of mediocrity. They worship the same 3-4 names while ignoring the true artisans of the game. Nair didn’t just score runs-he redefined resilience. But you don’t get rewarded for integrity when the system is built on nepotism, PR, and IPL sponsorships. He’s not being overlooked-he’s being erased. And the worst part? No one’s even mad enough to protest.
  • Chandan Gond said:
    August 12, 2025 AT 17:02
    Karun, if you’re reading this-you’ve already won. The runs, the grit, the comeback? That’s legacy. The jersey? That’s just paper. Keep swinging. The world’s watching.
  • Hailey Parker said:
    August 14, 2025 AT 01:48
    So the selectors want ‘balance’... but the only thing balanced here is the scale of their hypocrisy. They say ‘experience’ but pick someone who’s been dropped 3 times. They say ‘form’ but ignore 863 runs. Meanwhile, Nair’s out there doing the work while they’re busy taking selfies with sponsors. 🤷‍♀️

Write a comment